Toasty Sandwich Shop Menu (Update 2025)
Introducing the Menu at Toasty Sandwich Shop
At the Toasty Sandwich Shop in Yonkers, NY, breakfast and brunch meet delicious creativity. This vibrant, Latinx-owned establishment serves a mouthwatering array of sandwiches, including classic bacon and egg rolls to unique offerings like the Freaking French Toast Sandwich, layered with ham and cheddar, drizzled with maple syrup.
The all-day breakfast options are impressive, featuring items such as the Master BLT Melt and NYC Style Grilled Cheese. Delight in the variety of omelettes, from cheesy to veggie, crafted with fresh ingredients.
For lunch, try the Buffalo Soldier sandwich, bursting with bold flavors of chicken and ranch. With accommodating features like wheelchair access and dog-friendly seating, Toasty Sandwich Shop truly welcomes all. Enjoy your meal in their heated outdoor area or take it home with their convenient takeout and delivery services. Don't forget the happy hour specials!
ALL DAY BREAKFAST
BACON & EGG
BACON + EGGS, TOASTED ROLL
BACON EGG & CHEESE ROLL
BACON, EGGS, MELTED AMERICAN CHEESE, MAYO, TOASTED ROLL
BUTTER ROLL COLD
TOASTED BUTTER ROLL
FRESH BUTTER, TOASTED ROLL
FREAKING FRENCH TOAST SANDWICH
TEXAS STYLE BREAD, FOREST HAM, FRIED EGGS, CHEDDAR CHEESE, MAPLE SYRUP
MASTER BLT MELT
BACON, MUENSTER CHEESE, LETTUCE,CHIPOTLE MAYO, TOMATOES, TOASTED ROLL
MC LOVIN SANDWICH
EGG WHITES, CRISPY BACON, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, SPINACH, MAYO, TOASTED ROLL
NYC STYLE GRILLED CHEESE
TEXAS STYLE BREAD ; AMERICAN CHEESE ; BUTTER ; BACON ; GRILLED
CINNAMON FRENCH TOAST
CINNAMON DIPPED FRENCH TOAST, POWDER SUGAR
TOASTED BLT ROLL
BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, TOASTED ROLL
SAUSAGE - EGG - CHEESE
SAUSAGE, AMERICAN CHEESE, EGGS, MAYO
SNOOZE AM WRAP
SCRAMBLED EGGS, SAUSAGE, HASH BROWN, AMERICANCHEESE, SECRET SAUCE
THE HASHTAG
CRISPY HASH BROWN, CRISPY BACON, SMOKED GOUDA CHEESE,RANCH SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL
TOASTY AVOCADO MELT
TOASTED MULTICRAIN, FRESH AVOCADO, PROVOLONE CHEESE, BUTTER
TOP OF THE MORNING
SALSALITO TURKEY, PEPPER JACKCHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATOES,KETCHUP, MAYONNAISE, TOASTED ROLL
TURKEY BACON EGG CHEESE
TURKEY BACON, EGG, CHEESE, TOASTED ROLL
CHESSY OMELETTE
EGGS, CHEDDAR CHEESE, MOZARELLA CHEESE, MUENSTER CHEESE
CREATE YOUR OWN
MUSCLE MAKER OMELETTE
EGG WHITES, TURKEY, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, SPINACH, ONIONS, GREEN PEPPERS, WHITE OR WHEAT TOAST
TOASTY SIGNATURE OMELETTE
SAUSAGE, CRISPY BACON, HAM, MUENSTER CHEESE, ONIONS PEPPERS, WHITE TOAST
SUPREME OMELETTE
CRISPY BACON, HAM, AMERICAN CHEESE, GREEN PEPPERS,ONIONS, TOMATOES, WHITE OR WHEAT TOAST
VEGGIE OMELETTE
GREEN PEPPERS, SPINACH, ONIONS, WHITE OR WHEAT TOAST
OMELETTE'S
TOASTED SANDWICHES (ROLL BREAD)
BUFFALO SOLDIER
BLAZING BUFFALO CHICKEN, BACON, MUENSTER CHEESE, BUFFALO SAUCE, RANCH SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
CALIFORNIA LOVE
TURKEY, CRISPY BACON, AVOCADO, AMERICAN CHEESE, RANCH SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
CRUSHED MAN
PIT CRAFT TURKEY, SMOKED GOUDA CHEESE, HASH BROWN, BBQ SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
EL DICTADOR
HONEY TURKEY, CRISPY BACON, PROVOLONE CHEESE, HONEY MUSTARD, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
HERO JACK
SMOKED PIT TURKEY, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, BBQ SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
ITALIAN BOY
TURKEY, HAM, PROVOLONE CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, ITALIAN SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
LADY LOVER
GRILLED CHICKEN, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, AVOCADO, ONIONS, GREEN PEPPERS, VINAIGRETTE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
MAGIC CHOPPED CHEESE
MELTED AMERICAN CHEESE, GROUND BEEF, ONIONS, ROASTED PEPPERS, MAYONNAISE, KETCHUP, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
PARMIGIANO SANDWICH
CHICKEN CUTLET, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, MARINARA SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL
PASTRAMI MELT
SLICED PASTRAMI, MELTED CHEDDAR CHEESE, ONIONS, ROASTED PEPPERS, MAYO, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
ROASTED MELT
ROAST BEEF, MELTED AMERICAN CHEESE, CARAMELIZED ONIONS, MAYO, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
THE GARDEN
AVOCADO, ROASTED PEPPERS, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, RANCH SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
THE MIDNIGHT
CHICKEN CUTLET, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, CHEDDAR CHEESE, AOLI SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
TOASTY SUPREME
CRISPY FRIED CHICKEN, BACON, FRIENCH FRIES, SMOKED GOUDA CHEESE, CHIPOTLE SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
TOP SHELF
GRILLED CHICKEN, CHEDDAR CHEESE, BACON, MOZZARELLA STICKS, CHIPOTLE SAUCE, RANCH SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
TUNA MELT
FRESH TUNA, ONIONS, TOMATOES, AMERICAN CHEESE, TOASTED ROLL
Create Your Own sandwich
TOASTED SANDWICHE'S (HERO BREAD)
TOASTY WRAP'S
BACON RANCH WRAP
GRILLED CHICKEN, CRISPY BACON, AMERICAN CHEESE, RANCH SAUCE, TORTILLA WRAP
BBQ CRUNCH WRAP
GROUND BEEF, FRIES, CARAMELIZED ONIONS, AMERICAN CHEESE, BBQ SAUCE, TORTILLA WRAP
FIRE WRAP
SALSALITO TURKEY, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, CHIPOTLE SAUCE, TORTILLA WRAP
GO GREEN WRAP
AVOCADO, SPINACH, TOMATOES, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, BALSAMIC SAUCE, GREEN TORTILLA WRAP
PIKEN BURGER FRIES
DOUBLE MEAT, BACON, AVOCADO CHEDDAR CHEESE & CHIPOTLE SAUCE + FRENCH FRIES
SPICY CHICKEN SANDWICH FRIES
CHICKEN CUTLET, MUENSTER CHEESE, RANCH & BUFFALO SAUCE + FRENCH FRIES
TOASTY BURGER FRIES
SMASHED PATTY, AMERICAN CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, MAYO KETCHUP + FRENCH FRIES
CHEESE BURGER FRIES CAN SODA
TOASTY BURGER'S
TOASTY BOWLS (rice)
BUFFALO CHICKEN BOWL
Fried chicken tenderloins, avocado, roasted cauliflower, celery, marinated cherry tomatoes, seed mix, blue cheese crumbles, Frank's Hot Sauce, your choice of grains with our greens blend and BBQ ranch (served on side).
EDAMAME FALAFEL BOWL
Crispy edamame falafel, cucumber namasu, roasted corn, marinated cherry tomatoes, black beans, seed blend, your choice of grains with our greens blend and Tzatziki dressing (served on side).
FRIED CHICKEN BOWL
Fried chicken tenders, avocado, roasted corn, marinated cherry tomatoes, black beans, cucumber namasu, cheddar cheese, crispy onions, your choice of grains with our greens blend and BBQ Ranch (served on side).
PLANT BASED BOWL ( VEGAN )
Plant-based tenders, cucumber namasu, roasted cauliflower, black beans, tofu, roasted broccoli, seed blend, your choice of grains with our greens blend and Sesame dressing (served on side).
APPLE CRISP CHICKEN SALAD
GRILLED CHICKEN, GREEN APPLE, LETTUCE, TONATOES, CROUTONS, VINAGRRETTE
B.L.T SALAD
CRISPY BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, CROUTONS, ITALIAN DRESSING
BASIC SALAD
LETTUCE, TOMATOES, ONIONS, DRESSING OF CHOICE
BUFFALO CHICKEN SALAD
Fried chicken tenders, avocado, roasted cauliflower, celery, marinated cherry tomatoes, seed mix, blue cheese crumbles, Frank's Hot Sauce, our greens blend and BBQ Ranch (served on side).
CHICKEN CEASER SALAD
GRILLED CHICKEN, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, CROUTONS, CEASER DRESSING
CRISPY CHICKEN SALAD
CHICKEN CUTLET, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, PARMESAN, CROUTONS, RANCH DRESSING
EDAMAME FALAFEL SALAD
Crispy edamame falafel, cucumber namasu, roasted corn, marinated cherry tomatoes, black beans, seed blend, salad greens blend and Tzatziki dressing (served on side).
FRIED CHICKEN SALAD
Fried chicken tenders, avocado, corn, marinated cherry tomatoes, black beans, cucumber namasu, cheddar cheese, crispy onions, our greens blend and BBQ Ranch (served on side).
PLANT BASED SALAD ( VEGAN )
Plant-based tenders, cucumber namasu, roasted cauliflower, roasted broccoli, black beans, firm tofu, seed blend, our greens blend and Sesame Dressing (served on side).
TOASTY SALAD BOWLS
BAGEL'S
BAGEL MANIA
CREAM CHEESE, EGGS, CHEDDAR CHEESE, CRISPY BACON
BAGEL WITH BACON & CHEESE
TOASTED BAGEL, BACON, AMERICAN CHEESE
BAGEL WITH BUTTER AND JELLY
BAGEL WITH CREAM CHEESE
TOASTED BAGEL, CREAM CHEESE
BAGEL WITH MELTED BUTTER
TOASTED BAGEL, MELTED BUTTER
TOASTED PLAIN BAGEL
TOASTED PLAIN BAGEL
BACON SUPREME FRIES
CRISPY BACON, AMERICAN CHEESE, FRENCH FRIES, CHIPOTLE SAUCE
BACON SUPREME FRIES LARGE
CRISPY BACON, AMERICAN CHEESE, CHIPOTLE SAUCE
BUFFALO CHICKEN CHEESE FRIES
CRISPY CHICKEN, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, FRENCH FRIES, BUFFALO SAUCE, RANCH SAUCE
BUFFALO CHICKEN CHEESE FRIES LARGE
CHICKEN CUTLET, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, RANCH, BUFFALO SAUCE
CHEESY QUESADILLA
FRESH TORTILLA, AMERICAN CHEESE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE
CHOPPED CHEESE FRIES
GROUND BEEF, ONIONS, GREEN PEPPERS, AMERICAN CHEESE, FRENCH FRIES, KETCHUP, MAYO
CHOPPED CHEESE FRIES LARGE
GROUND BEEF, AMERICAN CHEESE, KETCHUP, MAYO
CRISPY CHICKEN TENDERS (6)
CRISPY CHICKEN WINGS (6)
CRISPY ONION RINGS
MELTED CHEESE FRIES
MELTED AMERICAN CHEESE, FRENCH FRIES
MELTED MOZZARELLA STICKS (6)
ORIGINAL FRENCH FRIES
GOLDEN FRENCH FRIES
PEPPERONI FRIES
MELTED MOZZARELLA CHEESE, PEPPERONIS, FRENCH FRIES, MARINARA SAUCE
PEPPERONI FRIES LARGE
FRESH PEPPERONI, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, MARINARA SAUCE
MUNCHIE'Z
MUNCHIE'Z 2
BACON SUPREME FRIES SMALL
CRISPY BACON, AMERICAN CHEESE, FRENCH FRIES, CHIPOTLE SAUCE
BUFFALO CHICKEN CHEESE FRIES SMALL
CHICKEN CUTLET, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, RANCH, BUFFALO SAUCE
CHOPPED CHEESE FRIES SMALL
GROUND BEEF, AMERICAN CHEESE, KETCHUP, MAYO
PEPPERONI FRIES SMALL
FRESH PEPPERONI, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, MARINARA SAUCE
BOARS HEAD BLT
BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, TOASTED ROLL
BOARS HEAD - EGG & CHEESE ON A ROLL
TOASTED ROLL, EGGS, AMERICAN CHEESE
BOARS HEAD - EGG ON A ROLL
TOASTED ROLL , EGGS
BOARS HEAD - EGG WHITE'S ON A ROLL
TOASTED ROLL, EGG WHITE'S
BOARS HEAD - GRILLED CHEESE
WHITE OR WHEAT TOAST, AMERICAN CHEESE, BUTTER
BOARS HEAD - HUNGRY MAN
3 EGGS, BACON, HAM, SAUSAGE, AMERICAN CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATOES
BOARS HEAD - BREAKFAST
BOARS HEAD - SANDWICHE'S
HONEY BEE
MAPLE HONEY TURKEY, DELUXE HAM, MUENSTER CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO, HONEY MUSTARD SAUCE, TOASTED HERO
SOUTHERN STYLE
ROAST BEEF, CHEDDAR CHEESE, GRILLED ONIONS, HORSERADISH SAUCE, TOASTED HERO
THE CLASSIC
OVEN GOLD TURKEY, CHEDDAR CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO, CHOICE OF DRESSING, TOASTED HERO
CHOPPED CHIPOTLE CHEESE
CHIPOTLE CHICKEN, MELTED PEPPER JACK CHEESE, PEPPERS, ONIONS, TOASTED HERO
SANTA FE
SALSALITO TURKEY, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO, CHIPOTLE SAUCE, TOASTED HERO
THE NEW YORKER
PASTRAMI, SWISS CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO, MUSTARD
CALIFORNIA TURKEY
OVEN GOLD TURKEY, MUENSTER CHEESE, AVOCADO, LETTUCE, TOMATO, SUNDRIED TOMATO PESTO MAYO
CRISP & SWEET
Maple Honey Turkey Mozzarella, apple & Honey MustardMAPLE HONEY TURKEY, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, SLICED APPLE, HONEY MUSTARD
HOT & SPICY
BLAZING BUFFALO CHICKEN, BACON, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO, CHIPOTLE SAUCE
SMOKE MASTER
SMOKE MASTER, BLACK FOREST HAM, SWISS CHEESE, ROASTED PEPPERS, MUSTARD SAUCE
THE RUSSIAN
DELUXE ROAST BEEF, COLESLAW, RUSSIAN DRESSING
TURKEY CLUB
PITCRAFT TURKEY, BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATO
WRAP CHICKEN CEASER
GRILLED CHICKEN, PARMESAN CHEESE, LETTUCE, CROUTONS, CEASER DRESSING
BOARS HEAD - WRAP'S
SMOOTHIE'S
BANANA SUNSHINE
FRESH BANANA, HONEY, WHOLE MILK
BLUE'S CLUE
BLUEBERRY, APPLE, BANANA, CHOICE OF WATER OR MILK
CARRIBEAN BREEZE
MANGO, STRAWBERRY, PINEAPPLE, CHOICE OF WATER OR MILK
DAILY DETOX
GREEN APPLE, SPINACH, PINEAPPLE, CHOICE OF WATER OR MILK
GREEN MACHINE
GREEN APPLE, KIWI, SPINACH, CHOICE OF WATER OR MILK
HEALTHYHOLIC
GREEN APPLE, HONEY, PINEAPPLE, CHOICE OF WATER OR MILK
CREATE YOUR OWN SMOOTHIE
3 FRUITS IN TOTALSTRAWBERRY, MANGO, PINEAAPPLE, SPINACH, KIWI, RASPBERRY, BLUEBERRY CHOICE OF WATER OR MILK
TROPICAL SUN
STRAWBERRY, BANANA, MANGO, CHOICE OF WATER OR MILK
WILDBERRY
STRAWBERRY, BLUEBERRY, RASPBERRY, CHOICE OF WATER OR MILK
ADD WHIPPED CREAM
WHIP CREAM
COLD SODA
COCA COLAPEPSIGINGER ALESPRITEFANTASELTZER
COLD WATER
POLAND SPRING
ICED CARAMEL LATTE
16 OZ, FRESH BREWED COFFEE, CARAMEL
ICED COFFEE
16 OZ, FRESH BREWED COFFEE, MILK OR HALF & HALF
ICED HAZELNUT LATTE
16 OZ, FRESH BREWED COFFEE, HAZELNUT
ICED MOCHA LATTE
16 OZ, FRESH BREWED COFFEE, MOCHA
SNAPPLE
KIWI STRAWBERRYORANGEICED TEAPEACH
COLD DRINK'S
HOT DRINK'S
ADD ON - WHIP CREAM
WHIP CREAM
BLENDED BEAN COFFEE
12 OZ , FRESH BREWED COFFEE
CARAMEL LATTE
12 OZ , FRESH BREWED COFFEE, CARAMEL
CREAMY CAPPUCCINO
12 OZ , FRESH BREWED CAPPUCCINO
FRENCH VANILLA
12 OZ , FRESH BREWED COFFEE, FRENCH VANILLA
FRESH BREWED COFFEE
12 OZ , FRESH BREWED COFFEE
HOT CHOCOLATE
12 OZ , HOT CHOCOLATE
MOCHA LATTE
12 OZ , FRESH BREWED COFFEE, MOCHA
ROASTED ESPRESSO
ESPRESSO
VARIETY OF TEA
GREY EARLPEPPERMINTLEMONGREEN TEA